Tell critical from subcritical choke flow
A 32/64-in choke with 1,000 psia upstream and 400 psia downstream, passing a 35 °API oil at a GLR of 1,000 scf/STB: the pressure ratio against the 0.55 rule of thumb, the Sachdeva critical pressure ratio for this fluid, the rate, the highest downstream pressure the choke stays critical at, and the rate as the downstream pressure rises to the upstream.
- UC-SF-002
Engineering use case UC-SF-002 (Determine Critical vs Subcritical Flow).
Below a critical ratio of downstream to upstream pressure the mixture reaches sonic velocity in the throat and the rate stops responding to the downstream pressure; above it the rate falls with the pressure difference. Sachdeva et al. (1986) solve for the critical ratio from the free-gas quality, the specific volumes and the polytropic exponent of the mixture (Guo et al. 2007, Eqs. 5.13 to 5.21), and give the rate on either side of it. For a single-phase gas the ratio is (2 / (k + 1))^(k / (k − 1)).
What an engineer learns from it: the ratio is 0.40, critical by the 0.55 rule and by Sachdeva's 0.568 for this fluid, so the choke passes 1,899 bbl/d whatever the flowline does, up to 568 psia downstream. Above that the rate falls, to 1,733 bbl/d at 700 psia and 1,109 at 900, which is why a choke set against a rising separator or flowline pressure loses rate the Gilbert correlations cannot see (Gilbert gives 1,608 bbl/d here, whatever the downstream pressure). For a natural gas the critical ratio is 0.55 at k = 1.25 and 0.53 at k = 1.4.
Units: psia, bbl/d, scf/STB, °API, °F, inches. The Sachdeva defaults are k = 1.4 for the gas and a liquid heat capacity of 0.8 Btu/(lbm °F); the 0.55 rule is a screening value, not a property of the fluid.
Source
using System;
using System.Linq;
using Team76.Engineering.SF.Choke;
using Team76.Engineering.SF.Choke.MultiPhase;
using Team76.Engineering.SF.Choke.SinglePhase;
public class S : ICalcScript
{
public ScriptResult Run(ICalcContext ctx)
{
// The use case's choke: 1,000 psia upstream and 400 psia downstream. A 32/64-in bean passes a 35 °API oil with
// a GLR of 1,000 scf/STB of 0.75-gravity gas, no water, at 120 °F.
const double upstream = 1000, downstream = 400; // psia
const double choke = 0.5; // in
const double glr = 1000, api = 35, gasGravity = 0.75, waterCut = 0, temperature = 120;
var regime = ChokeFlowRegimeHelper.Determine(upstream, downstream); // against the 0.55 rule of thumb
var sachdeva = new SachdevaChoke();
double yc = sachdeva.CriticalPressureRatio(glr, api, gasGravity, upstream, temperature, waterCut); // Guo Eq. 5.13
double rate = SachdevaChoke.Rate(upstream, downstream, choke, glr, api, gasGravity, waterCut, temperature); // bbl/d
// The rate as the downstream pressure rises from 100 psia to just under the upstream: flat while the choke is
// critical, falling to nothing once it is not.
double[] downstreams = [100, 200, 300, 400, 500, 550, 600, 650, 700, 750, 800, 850, 900, 950, 990];
var curve = new ScriptSeries("Sachdeva", downstreams,
downstreams.Select(p2 => Math.Round(SachdevaChoke.Rate(upstream, p2, choke, glr, api, gasGravity, waterCut, temperature), 1)).ToArray());
// Single-phase gas: (2 / (k + 1))^(k / (k - 1)).
var gasRatios = new[] { 1.25, 1.28, 1.3, 1.4 }
.Select(k => new object[] { k, Math.Round(GasChoke.CriticalPressureRatio(k), 4) }).ToList();
return ctx.Result()
.Set("Pressure ratio p2/p1", downstream / upstream)
.Set("Regime by the 0.55 rule", regime.ToString())
.Set("Sachdeva critical ratio", Math.Round(yc, 4))
.Set("Critical by Sachdeva", downstream / upstream <= yc)
.Set("Sachdeva rate (bbl/d)", Math.Round(rate))
.Set("Highest downstream pressure still critical (psia)", Math.Round(yc * upstream))
.Set("Gilbert rate at the same upstream pressure (bbl/d)", Math.Round(GilbertChoke.Rate(upstream, choke, glr)))
.Set("Gas critical ratios", new ScriptTable(["k = Cp/Cv", "Critical ratio"], gasRatios))
.Set("Rate against downstream pressure", new ScriptChart([curve], title: "Sachdeva (1986), 32/64 in, 1,000 psia upstream", xLabel: "Downstream pressure (psia)", yLabel: "Liquid rate (bbl/d)"));
}
}