Compare vertical, horizontal and fractured completions
One 5 mD sand completed three ways: a vertical well as drilled and cleaned up, a 2,000 ft horizontal well by Joshi, and a fractured vertical well through the fracture's equivalent skin, at two fracture conductivities. Productivity index, the gain over the vertical well, and the fracture's dimensionless conductivity.
- UC-IPR-006
- UC-IPR-003
- UC-IPR-005
Engineering use cases UC-IPR-006 (Compare Well Completion Options), UC-IPR-003 (Evaluate Horizontal Well) and UC-IPR-005 (Assess Fracture Impact).
A fracture enters Darcy's law as a negative skin: HydraulicFracturing.EquivalentSkinFactor gives the skin that a vertical well with the fracture's effective wellbore radius would have, and the pseudosteady-state J follows. Its dimensionless conductivity, Cfd = kf w / (k xf), says which part limits it: below about 1 the fracture cannot carry what the rock delivers to it, above about 30 it carries everything and only length helps.
What an engineer learns: the 0.25" fracture of 50,000 mD proppant that suits a 1 mD rock has a Cfd of only 0.42 in this 5 mD one. It still makes five times the damaged vertical well's J, but the 2,000 ft horizontal well, at kv/kh of 0.1, beats it. Ten times the conductivity (Cfd 4.2) doubles the fracture's J and puts it ahead of the horizontal well: in a conductivity-limited fracture, proppant pays where more half-length would not. Removing the vertical well's skin of 5 alone gives two thirds more J: the cheapest option is often the acid job. The horizontal J is steady state by Joshi's method, a few per cent higher than a pseudosteady-state figure would be, so read the ranking, not the third decimal.
Units are field: mD, ft, cP, rb/STB; J in STB/d per psi. The rate column is J × 1,000 psi above the bubble point. Cost, which UC-IPR-006 ends on, is left to the reader.
Source
using System;
using System.Linq;
using Team76.Engineering.IPR;
public class S : ICalcScript
{
public ScriptResult Run(ICalcContext ctx)
{
// One 5 mD sand, 40 ft thick, 1.5 cP oil at 1.2 rb/STB, on 1,320 ft drainage radius, and three ways to complete it.
double k = 5, h = 40, mu = 1.5, bo = 1.2, re = 1320, rw = 0.354;
// A vertical well, as drilled (skin 5) and if the damage were removed.
var vertical = PseudosteadyState.ProductivityIndex(K: k, h: h, Bl: bo, Ul: mu, Re: re, Rw: rw, S: 5);
var verticalClean = PseudosteadyState.ProductivityIndex(K: k, h: h, Bl: bo, Ul: mu, Re: re, Rw: rw, S: 0);
// A 2,000 ft horizontal well, Joshi, with kv/kh = 0.1.
var horizontal = SteadyState.ProductivityIndexByJoshi(L: 2000, Rw: rw, Re: re, h: h, Kz: k * 0.1, Kxy: k, Bl: bo, Ul: mu);
// A vertical well with a 500 ft half-length, 0.25 in wide propped fracture of 50,000 mD, as an equivalent skin.
double xf = 500, wf = 0.25 / 12, kf = 50000;
var cfd = HydraulicFracturing.Cfd(kf, wf, k, xf);
var fractureSkin = HydraulicFracturing.EquivalentSkinFactor(Xf: xf, W: wf, K_fracture: kf, K: k, Rw: rw);
var fractured = PseudosteadyState.ProductivityIndex(K: k, h: h, Bl: bo, Ul: mu, Re: re, Rw: rw, S: fractureSkin);
// The same fracture with ten times the conductivity: wider, or a better proppant.
var fractureSkin10 = HydraulicFracturing.EquivalentSkinFactor(Xf: xf, W: wf, K_fracture: kf * 10, K: k, Rw: rw);
var fractured10 = PseudosteadyState.ProductivityIndex(K: k, h: h, Bl: bo, Ul: mu, Re: re, Rw: rw, S: fractureSkin10);
object[] Row(string option, double j, double skin, string model) =>
[option, Math.Round(j, 3), Math.Round(j / vertical, 1), Math.Round(j * 1000), Math.Round(skin, 2), model];
return ctx.Result()
.Set("Options", new ScriptTable(
["Completion", "J (STB/d/psi)", "× vertical as drilled", "Rate at 1,000 psi drawdown (STB/d)", "Skin", "Model"],
[Row("Vertical, skin 5", vertical, 5, "Darcy, pseudosteady state"),
Row("Vertical, skin 0", verticalClean, 0, "Darcy, pseudosteady state"),
Row("Horizontal, 2,000 ft", horizontal, 0, "Joshi, steady state"),
Row("Fractured, Cfd 0.42", fractured, fractureSkin, "Darcy with the fracture's equivalent skin"),
Row("Fractured, Cfd 4.2", fractured10, fractureSkin10, "Darcy with the fracture's equivalent skin")],
title: "Productivity of three completions in one sand"))
.Set("Fracture Cfd", Math.Round(cfd, 2))
.Set("Fracture effective wellbore radius (ft)", Math.Round(HydraulicFracturing.EffectiveWellboreRadius(xf, cfd), 1))
.Set("Verdict", cfd < 1
? "The fracture is conductivity-limited (Cfd below 1): more proppant conductivity pays before more length."
: "The fracture's conductivity is adequate: more length pays.");
}
}