Spend the proppant on the optimum fracture

A fixed mass of proppant in a square drainage area: the proppant number, the optimal dimensionless conductivity, the length and propped width that give the highest productivity, and that maximum dimensionless productivity index. Then a tight-oil well swept from 25,000 to 1.6 million lbm.

Open in the workbench

Engineering use case UC-FRAC-011 (Unified Fracture Design), with the conductivity of UC-FRAC-005 and the optimisation of UC-FRAC-010.

Economides' Unified Fracture Design measures the proppant in the pay with one number, N_prop = 2 k_f V_p / (k x_e² h), where V_p is the propped volume in the pay, both wings. For that number there is one optimal dimensionless conductivity C_fD = k_f w / (k x_f), 1.6 for any N_prop below 0.1, and one maximum dimensionless productivity index. The half-length and width follow from the pair: x_f = √(V_p k_f / (2 C_fD k h)), w = V_p / (2 x_f h).

What an engineer learns from it: the use case's 2,500 lbm in a 10 md sand gives N_prop = 0.0435, so the optimum is C_fD = 1.6, a 154 ft half-length and a 0.59 in propped width, and J_D = 0.391, the numbers the use case prints. A longer fracture with the same proppant would be too narrow to deliver what it drains; a shorter one would waste conductivity. In the tight-oil sweep the first doublings of proppant mostly buy length, 259 ft at 25,000 lbm to 633 ft at 200,000 lbm, while C_fD stays near 2. Past N_prop = 1 the length stops growing towards the drainage boundary and the extra proppant goes into width (1.5 in at 1.6 million lbm, a tip-screenout design), and J_D creeps towards 6/π = 1.909, the limit of linear flow in a square. That flattening is where a treatment stops paying.

Units: lbm, ft, in, md. The propped volume, drainage side and pay share one length unit, feet. J_D is the pseudo-steady-state dimensionless index, J = J_D k h / (141.2 B μ) in field units. The sweep assumes the proppant is placed in the pay in proportion to h / h_f and that the closure-stress pack permeability holds; non-Darcy flow and embedment lower the effective k_f.

Source

using System;
using System.Linq;
using Team76.Engineering.Frac.Design;

public class S : ICalcScript
{
    public ScriptResult Run(ICalcContext ctx)
    {
        // The use case's worked example: an 80-acre square drainage area in a 10 md sand, 2,500 lbm of ceramic
        // proppant (SG 3.3) packing at 20 % porosity and 50,000 md under closure, all of it in the pay.
        const double drainageSide = 1866.76; // ft, the side of an 80-acre square
        var design = UnifiedFractureDesign.OptimumFromProppantMass(
            proppantMass: 2500, proppantSpecificGravity: 3.3, proppantPackPorosity: 0.20,
            netPayHeight: 1, fractureHeight: 1,
            proppantPackPermeability: 50000, reservoirPermeability: 10, drainageSide: drainageSide);
        double proppedVolume = UnifiedFractureDesign.ProppedVolumeInPay(2500, 3.3, 0.20, 1, 1);

        // A tight-oil well on the same 80 acres: 1 md, 50 ft of pay inside a 65 ft fracture, 20/40 sand (SG 2.65)
        // packing at 35 % porosity and 60,000 md at closure. More proppant buys a longer, then a wider, fracture.
        var masses = new[] { 25000.0, 50000, 100000, 200000, 400000, 800000, 1600000 };
        var rows = masses.Select(m =>
        {
            var d = UnifiedFractureDesign.OptimumFromProppantMass(m, 2.65, 0.35, 50, 65, 60000, 1, drainageSide);
            return new object[]
            {
                m, Math.Round(d.ProppantNumber, 4), Math.Round(d.OptimalDimensionlessConductivity, 3),
                Math.Round(d.OptimalFractureHalfLengthFeet, 1), Math.Round(d.OptimalFractureWidthInches, 3),
                Math.Round(d.MaximumDimensionlessProductivityIndex, 3),
            };
        }).ToList();
        var numbers = rows.Select(r => (double)r[1]).ToArray();
        var limit = Math.Round(UnifiedFractureDesign.MaximumDimensionlessProductivityIndexLimit, 3);

        return ctx.Result()
            .Set("J_D against the proppant number", new ScriptChart(
                [new ScriptSeries("J_D,max", numbers, rows.Select(r => (double)r[5]).ToArray()),
                 new ScriptSeries("6/π limit", [numbers[0], numbers[^1]], [limit, limit])],
                title: "Unified Fracture Design", xLabel: "Proppant number", yLabel: "Dimensionless PI", xLog: true))
            .Set("Tight-oil proppant sweep", new ScriptTable(["Proppant (lbm)", "N_prop", "C_fD,opt", "x_f (ft)", "w (in)", "J_D,max"], rows))
            .Set("Propped volume in the pay (ft3)", Math.Round(proppedVolume, 3))
            .Set("Proppant number", Math.Round(design.ProppantNumber, 4))
            .Set("Optimal dimensionless conductivity", Math.Round(design.OptimalDimensionlessConductivity, 3))
            .Set("Optimum half-length (ft)", Math.Round(design.OptimalFractureHalfLengthFeet, 1))
            .Set("Optimum propped width (in)", Math.Round(design.OptimalFractureWidthInches, 3))
            .Set("Maximum dimensionless PI", Math.Round(design.MaximumDimensionlessProductivityIndex, 3))
            .Set("Maximum dimensionless PI limit", limit);
    }
}